Skip to main content

windows 7 - Computer restarts randomly - all parts A/B tested

Brief Intro: Computer, one fine day, started randomly restarting. No pattern seen. Occurs anywhere between 1 to 8-9 times a day, usually 2-5. Can go 2-3 days between occurrences. Restart does not involve BSOD. Event logs offer no hints. Temps aren't high - has happened during idle load. Details below, and in my first Q.


This Q follows up Computer irregularly restarts - what should service centre look for?


As of now, the motherboard has just been replaced by Gigabyte. CPU has been replaced, RAM has been replaced, but the problem of random reboots continues.


Below is a crude graphical guide to the permutations in which restarts have occurred.



Key:


WP = Main or Wall Power source
IP = Intermediate Power Source a.k.a UPS
PSU = Computer Power Supply Unit - Corsair 550M
Cs = Computer case/cabinet
MB = Motherboard GA-H97-D3H
RAM -  RC = 2x Corsair 4GB DDR3 1333
      RK1 = 1x Kingston 8GB DDR3 1600
      RK2 = 2x Kingston 8GB DDR3 1866
CPU = i5-4440
HDDs = WD 1TB Win 7 + Seagate 2TB OpenSuSE Linux Tumbleweed
OS = within Win7 / Linux / UEFI

No add-on graphics ever (at my end), only iGPU.


These are the scenarios in which the system has been tested. FAIL at the start means restart reproduced; PASS means no restarts seen.


If there's a suffix - it indicates a changed component. Trailing ? indicates that component may not have been present.


In chronological order,


FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB - RC - CPU - HDDs - Win
FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB - RC - CPU - HDDs - Linux 
FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB - RC - CPU - HDDs - BIOS

--- comp sent to dealer without HDDs --->

FAIL:  WP_dlr - IP_dlr? - PSU - Cs - MB - RC - CPU - HDDs_dlr - Win_dlr
PASS:  WP_dlr - IP_dlr? - PSU_dlr - Cs_dlr - MB - RC - CPU - HDDs_dlr - Win_dlr
(^ tested for less than a day)

--- comp returned to me with dealer PSU and Cs --->

FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU_dlr - Cs_dlr - MB - RC - CPU - HDDs - Win
FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU_dlr - Cs_dlr - MB - RK1 - CPU - HDDs - Win
(^ a week passed without restarts after switching to ram RK1)
FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU_dlr - Cs_dlr - MB - RK1 - CPU - HDDs - Linux

contd..


--- comp returned to dealer without HDDs --->
--- MB only forwarded to Gigabyte --->

PASS:  WP_gb - IP_gb? - PSU_gb - Cs_gb? - MB - R_gb - CPU_gb - HDDs_gb? - ?
(^ burn-in test for 2 days)
FAIL:  WP_gb - IP_gb? - PSU_gb - Cs_gb? - MB - RC - CPU - HDDs_gb? - ?
(^ sent my CPU + Corsair RAM)

--- Gigabyte return items to dealer; say one of the RC sticks to blame --->

PASS:  WP_dlr - IP_dlr? - PSU - Cs - MB - 1xRC + RK1 - CPU - HDDs_dlr - Win_dlr
(^ tested intermittently over 3-4 days)

--- comp returned to me with "faulty" RAM removed --->

FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB - 1xRC + RK1 - CPU - HDDs - Win

--- MB+CPU+RAM(RC+RK1) resent to Gigabyte --->

(no testing done; CPU examined - observed some pins have blackened; say CPU to blame)

--- dealer replaces CPU with same model --->

PASS:  WP_dlr - IP_dlr? - PSU_dlr - Cs_dlr - MB - 1xRC + RK1 - CPU_new - HDDs_dlr - Win_dlr
(^ tested for 3 days)

contd..


--- comp returned to me with new CPU --->

FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB - RC + RK1 - CPU_new - HDDs - Win
FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB - RC + RK1 - CPU_new - HDDs - BIOS

--- MB+CPU_new+RAM(RC+RK1) sent to Gigabyte --->

PASS:  WP_gb - IP_gb? - PSU_gb - Cs_gb? - MB - RC+RK1 - CPU_new - HDDs_gb? - ?
(^ testing setup and duration unknown but reported after 3 days; say PSU to blame)

At this stage, I call Gigabyte and explain testing history to site manager,
who offers replacement MB.

--- comp returned to me with RMAed MB --->

FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB_rma - RC + RK1 - CPU_new - HDDs - Win
PASS:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB_rma - RC + RK1 - CPU_new - HDDs - Linux
(^ a few hours)
FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB_rma - RC + RK1 - CPU_new - HDDs - BIOS

--- swap RAM with another (working) comp, yesterday --->

FAIL:  WP - IP - PSU - Cs - MB_rma - RK2 - CPU_new - HDDs - Win
(PASS:  WP_oth - PSU_oth - Cs_oth - MB_oth - RC + RK1 - CPU_oth - HDD_oth - Win)

Now thinking of what my next testing step is probably upgrading this to the theological department, but will check temporal suggestions a bit longer.


If you read the initial Q, you'll notice that the original MB was sent to Gigabyte in June. It was sent back repaired and with its BIOS upgraded to version F7. Version before was F3. The new version added support for 5th gen procs, they also prevent BIOS rollbacks. Could the new BIOS be responsible? The RMAed board has F7 as well. Against this possibility is the fact that the upgrade occurred in June and the restart behaviour started in mid-Oct.


The disappearing drive issue hasn't recurred since the first return to me from Gigabyte. No crashes during any Windows or Linux use.


I'll probably swap the PSU with the working comp, though an earlier config has been unsuccessfully tested with the dealer's PSU.


Thanks for reading. Thoughts?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts

Use Google instead of Bing with Windows 10 search

I want to use Google Chrome and Google search instead of Bing when I search in Windows 10. Google Chrome is launched when I click on web, but it's Bing search. (My default search engine on Google and Edge is http://www.google.com ) I haven't found how to configure that. Someone can help me ? Answer There is no way to change the default in Cortana itself but you can redirect it in Chrome. You said that it opens the results in the Chrome browser but it used Bing search right? There's a Chrome extension now that will redirect Bing to Google, DuckDuckGo, or Yahoo , whichever you prefer. More information on that in the second link.
Post a Comment
Read more

linux - Using an index to make grep faster?

I find myself grepping the same codebase over and over. While it works great, each command takes about 10 seconds, so I am thinking about ways to make it faster. So can grep use some sort of index? I understand an index probably won't help for complicated regexps, but I use mostly very simple patters. Does an indexer exist for this case? EDIT: I know about ctags and the like, but I would like to do full-text search. Answer what about cscope , does this match your shoes? Allows searching code for: all references to a symbol global definitions functions called by a function functions calling a function text string regular expression pattern a file files including a file
Post a Comment
Read more

How do I transmit a single hexadecimal value serial data in PuTTY using an Alt code?

I am trying to sent a specific hexadecimal value across a serial COM port using PuTTY. Specifically, I want to send the hex codes 9C, B6, FC, and 8B. I have looked up the Alt codes for these and they are 156, 182, 252, and 139 respectively. However, whenever I input the Alt codes, a preceding hex value of C2 is sent before 9C, B6, and 8B so the values that are sent are C2 9C, C2 B6, and C2 8B. The value for FC is changed to C3 FC. Why are these values being placed before the hex value and why is FC being changed altogether? To me, it seems like there is a problem internally converting the Alt code to hex. Is there a way to directly input hex values without using Alt codes in PuTTY? Answer What you're seeing is just ordinary text character set conversion. As far as PuTTY is concerned, you are typing (and reading) text , not raw binary data, therefore it has to convert the text to bytes in whatever configured character set before sending it over the wire. In other words, when y
Post a Comment
Read more

networking - Windows 10, can ping other PC but cannot access shared folders! What gives?

I have a computer running Windows 7 that shares a Git repo on drive D. Let's call this PC " win7 ". This repo is the origin of a project that we push to and pull from. The network is a wireless network. One PC on this network is running on Windows 10. Let's call this PC " win10 ". Win10 can ping every other PC on the network including win7 . Win7 can ping win10 . Win7 can access all shared files on win10 . Neither of the PCs have passwords. Problem : Win10 cannot access any shared files on win7 , not from Explorer, nor from Git Bash or any other Git management system (E-Git on Eclipse or Visual Studio). So, win10 cannot pull/push. Every other PC on the network can access win7 shared files and push/pull to/from the shared Git origin. What's wrong with Windows 10? I have tried these: Control Panel\All Control Panel Items\Network and Sharing Center\Advanced sharing settings\ File sharing is on, Discovery is on, Password protected sharing is off Adapte
Post a Comment
Read more